Dave,
I noticed the relief cut you made around the area that fits right at the muzzle and the way you cut the grooves so the tompion would properly compress. That's why I added I really liked your design. Probably should have been less succinct because I did notice that.
When I began reenacting Rev War and War of 1812 in the mid 70's, there were no original Brown Bess Tompions to be had, but there were still plenty of original Civil War Era .69 caliber tompions and many folks used them for their "Charlevilles." I still have 5 or 6 of those original New Old Stock tompions as many folks do not "do" the other period reenacting and there are a lot of repro's out there now. Now, I knew and know just because an original piece was made for ".69" caliber, that doesn't mean it is going to fit and you may/will have to fit it to the musket.
When I began reenacting the Civil War in 1981, we still had plenty of original .58 caliber Tompions that many of us used for our reproduction muskets after adjusting them to the bore size. I have also seen the original British adjustable tompions for Enfield Rifle Muskets that you and TPH mentioned in excellent to mint condition, though I have personally never used an original in a repro musket. BTW, a very good friend and mentor at one time owned 7 original Whitworth Rifles and three of them were in the original cased sets. Two of the cased sets still had the adjustable tompion in it and in the Mint Cased set, it was beautiful.
At the World Championship I worked at in Quantico and the two I attended in Wedgnock, UK as the USIMLT Armourer, I was privileged to see many really nice 19th and some 18th century tompions for British and a couple for French guns.
I did not mean to imply Dave's tompions were not good and I hope no one took it that way.
I have seen plenty of stuck Tompions over the years in Virginia from Reenactors doing Rev War through Civil War and at the North South Skirmish Association Spring and Fall Championships I attended as a gunsmith for over 20 years between 1974 and 2005. Whenever I attended a reenactment or a shoot, I always carried these pliers with me and I often had to use them to get the stuck Tompions out after we had to ruin one tompion to get it out in the early 80's.
http://www.brownells.com/.aspx/pid=13787/Product/MAGAZINE_TUBE_CAP_PLIERSNow, most all of the stuck tompions I took out probably were repro's and not made properly and/or were not fitted to the gun's muzzle they were stuck in. If someone does not have much experience with tompions, I'm sure they will get something out of this thread because of the problems that will occur when tompions are not made or fitted properly.
TPH, you don't know how much I envy you working those nine days on the movie "Gettysburg." I had to give up command of the 47th VA Inf Regiment about 9 months before the movie shoot was shot because I was getting transferred to Camp Pendleton, CA. I was also second in command and the "Tactical" Officer of Longstreet's Corps in those days. Chuck Hillsman offered me command of a Confederate Regiment for the movie, but I could not get 45 days leave to do it as that was the original plan before production. It was only later they pared that down to the nine days you mentioned and had I known that, I would have come back for it. When the camera "pans" across the troops before Pickett's Charge, I used to be able to name almost every person there. My old unit the 47th VA was in the movie, but I've never been able to pick them out as they were much further down the Battle Line.