LOL- back then, we used that GOI powder, Meteor along Curtis & Harvey powder. The GOI developed better ballistics than the Meteor or C&H of the day, granulation to granulation. I do recall some of it really did foul badly - just tightened up the ball and patch combinations, is all- good results happened.
One .58 I had used 165gr. 2F GO with the 675gr. slightly modified #57730 Lyman Minnie to get 1,325fps. A mere 150gr. got it going 1,250fps. Those kicked a bit- especially with the hooked & narrow Hawken butt plate.
I also list 200gr. of 2F G-O powder making 1,850fps with a .022" denim patched round ball of .575" diameter. According to Lyman's book of the day that load developed about 10,200LUP - which is 1,000LUP less than a 32" bl. .50 produced with 80gr. G-O 3F, or a .36 produced with 45gr. 3F.
Recoil, however is a different matter.