I agree that browning gives the best protection to your metal parts. My deer rifle was browned over 20 years ago and I didn't do that great of a job, I was too impatient. So now the browning is thin and a lot of spots are worn down to bare metal. I wax my metal parts and even though this rifle has endured a lot of rain and moisture, and a lot of handling, I have never seen any sign of rust beginning. I now try for a deep, dark color which seems to give me even better protection from rain and handling.
My rifles are all hunting guns and maybe browning is not PC but I will continue using it because of the protection it gives.