I think it's an excellent knife with very good proportions. Personally, I need a knife with at least a four inch handle and a cutting edge of less than five inches but at least 2.75 or so. Large Bowie knives are impressive but aren't all that useful in camp or when dressing game. I especially like the black walnut scales as that is one of my favorite woods. Yes, it probably isn't at all period correct with the exception of the wood but you should be proud of your work.