I would use either -- the 20g more for plain pipes or ones with stamped in detail or the 18g, esp. if you want to file in the details. I used 16 g and it is too heavy, but I didn't worry about filing through and there was plenty of room to ream it out for a good fit on the ramrod. 18g should be better, maybe still a little heavier than necessary, but it shouldn't cause you any trouble forming it.