As a relative novice concerning longrifles (started about 2 years ago and really dug in the last year), I have been curious about statements I read on forums about how modern "Hawken" style rifles really don't replicate the originals. Some speak with some derision about production "Hawken" rifles.
So, I paid special attention at the actual J.S., Samuel, W.S. Hawken rifles that were displayed in the Cody museum. After a day-and-a-half at the museum, I was utterly exhausted, particularly after seeing the 1500 firearm collection lent by the Smithsonian!
Up for discussion are these original Hawken rifles along with one Gemmer. I have added the information labels to the pictured rifles and added more visible numbers to link the rifles to the informational placards.
There are several full stock Hawken rifles. There were no flintlocks exhibited. All seem to have 2 wedge pins whereas all production "Hawken style" files have one, except for the Traditions Great Plains rifle. As you can see, my analysis so far is quite superficial, lacking insight into length of pull, drop, etc.
If anyone wants the original, large, 4 mb photos, please contact me by email and I will be happy to send them.
Ron