Dphariss, Just curious but what do you use as your drying agent in the boiled linseed oil?
Store bought oil generally has a pretty good drier package but it is pretty acid and this inhibits the drying or so I have been told by "Ogre". This makes it a very poor stock finish as it comes from the store.
This lack of proper processing of modern "boiled" linseed oil, I believe it is cold processed now, is why it developed such a bad rep as a stock finish.
I add just about a tablespoon to the gallon of Japan drier. I sometimes add some oxidized roundballs but cannot see this does anything. Too little lead I suspect.
Killing the organic acids in the oil and heating it to thicken and darken it makes a true stock finish and makes it safe to use for oil cloth and other projects as well. Linseed with high acid levels will rot cloth when making oil cloth.
Problems such as these stemming from improperly prepared oil for our purpose is, I believe, why some are so quick to dismiss linseed oil as a stock finish.
All linseed oil is not created equal.
Dan