BTW, it doesn't appear that you got shoe polish in the grooves of the bands. I think it would high-light your turning work. Just my 2 cents worth.
In thinking about it, you may try in a tiny spot some fine Scotchbrite pad. Rub VERY lightly so as not to go through your stain in a test spot. May dull it slightly. Did you use Feibings or Lincoln leather dye?
Still, I like it as it is. God bless, Marc