First make sure your cap is bottoming out on the nipple. A nipple with even a small amount of distortion at its top can make a gun never fire on the first hammer fall. Chuck the nipple in your electric drill and gently releave the top edge of the nipple.
Most mainsprings can be retempered, but success rarely occurs on the first try. So locate another spring just in case. Metal suppliers, and welding shops, have a special crayon that only marks hot metal at a specific heat. This will help you know what when you have reached the proper tempering heat.
You should also check the fit of the tumbler where it penetrates the plate, and the bridle, they should not bind at all.
I kept an old CVA Mountain Rifle going for a lot of years using these tricks.
Hungry Horse