Jerry,
Besides possibly very inferior workmanship, how can one tell the difference between the two "W.Richards"? I have a W.Richards double in 16Ga with 36" barrels, checkering and very nice architecture that I plan to shoot. I have had it checked and it appears to be in good sound condition. I will pull the barrels and check the proof marks. HAve pilled the barrels off this gun and found: Liege proof mark (ELG in and oval), initials "LJM" in several places, a shield with a star over it, #895 on the rib and breach, and a very fanciful #3 made with double lines in several places. These are all under the barrel. Inside the lock plates are th initials "JA". That's it.
Mark