Jerry, I've stocked a couple of longrifles in quilted maple, and you are correct. It is soft, spongy, very flexible, and difficult to finish well. Of course, there will be exceptions to this, but I won't be using it again. One gets corrupted with good, dense, hard, heavy maple. The piece I'm working right now is a piece of nice western maple. It is nowhere near what the last piece of NY sugar maple was, but I'm enjoying working it. It's like super hard and dense English walnut - a pleasure to carve.