Guys,
I have made the frizzens from a variety of materials. It is boring to do the same thing every time. In truth, I like to get experience by trying different methods that were used 250 years ago.
Specifically I have forged frizzens in three ways.
1. Case hardened wrought iron. This is the most difficult because even after you forge and finish the frizzen, it must be hardened. I use 1/3 bone charcoal, 1/3 leather charcoal, 1/3 hardwood charcoal. The soft frizzen is covered in the charcoal, put in a small metal pot - I use an old lead melting pot with a flat metal plate lid. Next the pot is heated orange in a forge for several hours. This is boring so I try to have some other hot job to do during this time. I take the frizzen out of the charcoal, reheat to orange and quench in brine. I have no idea how deep hardened surface is, but the frizzens last a long time.
2. Sole plate frizzen. Here the wrought iron frizzen remains soft and a thin plate of steel is riveted to the face. I use 1095 and three iron rivets, then the whole thing is hardened. The drawback to this method is when the frizzen is quenched the sole plate tends to warp giving a tiny gap in places between the iron frizzen and the sole plate. I have not found a solution. I know of other gunsmiths who solder the sole plate on, but this would seem to me that the sole plate is softened in the process.
3. Forge the entire frizzen out of 1095, finish and harden. This way seems to be the best.
Jim Everett