Sorry Wade, I just now saw you posting from last week. I guess my opinion is that people should experiment, and go with what they find most suitable for their taste and the project they are working on. Myself, I have used aquafortis on a few stocks and like the look. It may sometimes turn almost a smokey black, but with a little elbow grease and maybe some steel wool and 360 paper it can be rubbed back, and underneath is, what to me looks like very old, aged cherry, kind of like my Grandmothers beautiful, old, favorite rocking chair. I have experimented with lye on same blank pieces and it looks artificial to me, but that is just me. someone else may look at the same piece of wood and feel that is just the ticket. There is almost no accounting for what goes on at the behind side of the eyes.
Robby