Dan, I disagree with your premise that ALL these inlays were mass produced. Proof that this is NOT the case is
right here in the library under "tools of a gunsmith". Wm. Shreckengost's vast array of inlay templates are intact to this day
in a local collection and the cardboard they were cut from shows the partial name of a local hardware store here
in western PA. In other words he repurposed the hardware store boxes to make his templates.
I find it hard to grasp how I can spend my time
tracking down things to post on this forum for guys to learn from and
have guys look at them and refuse to acknowledge what they are seeing.
You don't need a template if you are buying them already cut out.
As for already engraved, this is also not the case. I won't bother with the electron microscope to prove that the
gravers and shaders were used on his guns and no others. It's clearly his hand on all his rifles.
Yes, there were mass produced inlays on later rifles, but the examples I provided were not.
Please note: "Many" does not mean "all".
I fail to understand how someone could not understand this.
My comments regarding PURCHASED gun parts was simply an attempt to shed some light on the discussion. That using parts made by others has been a part of American firearms manufacture since DAY ONE is not even arguable. I am sorry if this interferes with some premise but its a fact.
If you REALLY want to understand the gun trade then you need to look for commercial sources. People just love, for example, to think that gunsmiths of the 18th c made their own barrels when in reality they bought most barrels and locks from EUROPE or for barrels at least from barrel forgers in PA by the 1770s. I know that by the 1860-70s there were hardware store catalogs with everything from ladies underwear to gun parts, including inlays, to baby carriages to freight wagons shown. The railroads changed EVERYTHING. There are inlays, like the key escutcheons on the Atchinson Hawken that appear in identical or slightly modified form from Coast to Coast on 19th c rifles, including one of the rifles you pictured.
Did Shreckengost make ALL the inlays and patchboxes?
Its entirely possible he did, but its also possible he bought some or copied them or at least copied some details given the time frame.
I think if you will look you will find that similar scroll shapes are found on rifles from the late 18th c onwards almost everywhere. Done right and in the right place its an attractive feature. Its used as decoration on both forends and buttstocks. Seems like a similar scroll was used on Bedfords as forend escutcheons. In fact a similar design is worked into the side plates on the silver patchbox of the Atchinson Hawken made in 1836. I am sure the inlays on this rifle were purchased in St Louis rather than shop made.
If we look at the late fancy rifles in "Kentucky Rifles and Pistols 1750-1850" there are several versions of this scroll design as inlays, sideplates and in patchbox sideplates. This being the case trying to give it some special meaning to someones use of it is simply not possible. It seems to be a common
design element used on American rifles. If one LOOKS for it.
The 4 lines crossing as an engraving pattern, representing an 8 point star maybe, are found elsewhere as well. Its something to fill an empty space and "dress it up". Does the star represent the baby Jesus? Could be. The Fish might represent Christianity as well etc etc. But unless we can get into the MAKERS head its SUPPOSITION. There are other instances of folk art appearing on rifles and then similar art on stone work in America. Especially when the stone work is associated with a rifle maker. Squire Boone for example.
By the end of the first quarter of the 19th c. inlays were replacing carving as stock decorations in America. If someone here can figure out the "symbolism" of the apparent "loaded in a shotgun and shot into the stock" inlay decoration often found on guns of the 19th c, including the cheek side of the Atchinson Hawken, please feel free to post it here. Or write a book.
For example is this a stylized "Allentown Indian"? Probably not. But if we want to suppose we can suppose anything.
.
Gunmakers would find or invent a striking design and USE it or ELEMENTS of it. They did not have the computer to help them find things so assuming that some gunmaker (or many) has included an inlay resembling some obscure design for some secret meaning is unlikely.
Religious symbols might apply in some cases. But while Beck used INRI he did not use more overt signs that I know of.
Masonic symbols are not that uncommon. The square and compass for example.
PA Dutch/German folk art might be used or the folk art might be influenced by the firearms decoration. How anyone could be surprised to find PA folk art on a rifle from PA or rifles made anywhere a PA rifle might be carried to its a surprise in itself.
If people put forth ideas here they will provoke discussion. I had no idea that mentioning a common truth, purchased gun parts, regarding American firearms making would gore an ox.
Dan