Kinda of hard to describe just how tight the plug should be when fully indexed but, here is a try. When you finally snug a plug up to the perfect 12 o'clock position, it should go in with only "firm" pressure. You shouldn't have to pull on it like t a weight lifter to get it into position. Dong this will gall out the threads and create a loose fit. You don't want it so loose that finger tightening gets you to within one flat of 12 o'clock and you only have to lightly tug it into position with slight pressure. When everything is done right, the shoulders of the plug mate up with no gaps to the squared off breech of the barrel and the face of the plug mates up snugly with the shoulder inside of the barrel at the bottom of the threaded portion of the breech. Hope this helps!