I have both kinds, too, but not by choice. I bought both bags from Townsend, and the first one I've almost used up is the "messy" variety, and the recent bag has the movie star wig look. It's a PITA, because it has to be rubbed up a lot to wind up on my worm. It works, but requires some preparation. I like the messy kind, but you don't know what you're getting from on-line descriptions.