I think 1 part acid to 2 parts water is a little strong. Make sure you test it on a scrap of the same board you made the stock from. I suspect it will be very dark. I use 4 to 1 when I make it.
Bill
I want it really dark on this rifle. You may be right though, it may be strong. I will definitely test it on a piece of scrap. Maybe I should split the middle and go 3:1.
Aqua fortis does what it does. Adding more, or making it "stronger" will not make it darker.
The solution you use doesn't really matter (though it does have to have a certain amount of acid, or there just ain't enough for it to function). The water evaporates away, leaving only the good stuff, so it doesn't matter how much water you start with.
Diluting it down only "stretches" your stain to make it last longer.
I have some that's 3:1, 4:1, and 6:1. All are exactly the same.
On sugar maple, AF tends to color lighter, and more orange-red. On red maple, it tends to color more brown and darker. The softer the wood, generally I have found the darker it will color...but then I avoid anything softer than the HARDEST red maple, and usually limit myself to hard sugar maple.
That said, each individual piece of wood is different, and a certain piece of wood might want to color differently than the next piece of wood of the same species, using the same staining technique.