I've only done one, but it came out the way I wanted. I stained and blushed the hickory with Aqua Fortis. Got a tiny bit of charring in one spot, but no biggie. Since that hickory seemed as hard a woodpecker lips, it didn't get as dark as I wanted after two coats. I overstained it with walnut wood stained, wiped off fairly quickly. That did the trick, and the color matched my rifle. I used low-gloss Tung Oil for the top finish. Considering the gradeau in a fired barrel, I don't like the idea of an open finish on a rod. The Tung Oil at least puts a hard finish on top. So far, the rod looks good. God Bless, Marc