Mike, thank you for this fine rifle, and thank you for applying the punched decoration. We speculated that the stippling might suggest a lowered background from relief carving, allowing the "high areas" and cheekpiece to seem to stand above, but that was only a guess from the aged appearance of the original. What do you think? It certainly does highlight the design. Did you do anything different with stain in the stamped areas, or did the punched circles take more stain to appear darker? You may be the second person since 1774 to apply this technique!
Hungry Horse, I found the same names you have, beginning with Kuykendahl in upstate New York, spilling into New Jersey where some adopted Coykendall, then south to Salisbury, NC, on to Virginia, Kentucky, Arkansas, first into Texas and on. I believe this old rifle came from an elderly lady named Kirkendall in New Mexico, who had no relatives that wanted the rifle. Thanks for a great post, Bob