What color do you want? HH is right about the smoke. Plus, different woodsmokes produce different colors. I've smoked deer skins with many different types of wood: cedar, pine, sagebrush, willow, pine needles, other unidentified punk wood, others. Willow gives a nice golden color; pine, somewhat brown; sagebrush a grayish tone; pine needles a light brownish tan. Of course, the longer you smoke it, the darker it gets. Braintan can also be colored with pigments, red and yellow ocher immediately come to mind. Other earth stains/pigments will work as well, but they tend to fade and "bleed" and stain your body and other clothing until they "set." Laundry bluing was an old-time favorite, although decidedly not 18thC. Some really good references are Blue Mountain Buckskin, by Jim Riggs; Buckskin: The Ancient Art of Brain Tanning, by Steven Edholm and Tamara Wilder; and Deerskins Into Buckskins, by Matt Richards, both book and DVD. They are all excellent references, although my personal belief is that if you buy Richards, get the DVD. It is pretty straightforward, while the book is not as much. There's a lot more I could write, but won't for now. HTH. --JB