I've always been a shooter first and a connoisseur of period correctness second (really 3rd or higher LOL). I've shot traditional muzzleloaders since 1975 and flint since 1980. I never forget my muzzleloading roots and still shoot percussion Thompson Centers occasionally. Heck sometimes I've had a hankering to buy me my first muzzleloader. A CVA Kentucky out of nostalgia and bring back old good memories.
I can see a professional builder and a guy that is into historical trekking wanting a rifle/musket that was made exactly like something Boone, Kenton, or Girty would carry back in the day. That is their passion. I'm okay that my Dixie TMR looks sort of like a period correct southern rifle. I'm also okay that my Kibler SMR is even closer if not correct.
Looking back, I've wasted/spent enough money on muzzleloaders over the years to buy one of the fine rifles Mr. Brooks, Mr. Chambers, or Fred builds. I wish I had taken that route and become "one" with the rifle. Sort of like Mark Baker's Moriah instead of dabbling in so many. Now I need to sell a few to buy that Woodsrunner!.................Bob