Thanks again. I'm pretty proud of the scrap iron I used to make the toeplate, it's from an old antique spatula knife blade, with lots of patina. I don't even need to do anything to "finish" it, it has a 150 years of finish.
Yesterday I stopped at Home Depot to see if they had any countersink tools, I got one that might work, I have to try it on some scrap first. Hate to mess up that plate I had to carefully cut out of the blade!
All the original southern rifles I have have flush, flat screws or nails. My decision to add a toeplate was because every one of the original southern mountain rifles, or Appalachian School, have one. Plus I will shoot this from the bench a lot, and don't want to risk scratching up the metal. I've been thinking about their original purpose. Everybody thinks it's to protect the sharp point of the toe from breaking off. But if that were the only reason, why would rifles that don't have an extremely curved buttplate have a toeplate? I think it's because hunters would shoot prone from time to time, and it was to keep the wood from getting chewed up from rocks and roots.