Hi Rich,
My vote, based only upon conjecture, is to draw file the old barrel as well as clean up other parts… within reason. “Pragmatic” is a good description of Yankee gunsmiths, but stocking old parts with no attempt at cleaning them up would go beyond that and into the realm of crude.That’s not to say it didn’t happen, though. Personally, I’d like to see deeper pits and scratches left, with the more superficial surface flaws filed out. Maybe give yourself a time limit so you clean it up as best you can without making it look brand new?
When you ream out the bores, would you mind sharing some photos of the process?
- Tom