Well, the stain was my own mix of Aqua Fortis. It just wouldn't get darker on the stock. I tried everything.
Now, my dad used the same stain and it's too dark for him. I wanted mine as dark as his, and he wanted his the same as mine.
I guess that's what you get with aqua fortis eh? Next time, I'll probably use the Homer Dangler Stain or the Laurel Mountain Forge stains.
Thanks for the positive feedback everyone.