Bama, i had the same problem with a tumbler blank that would not drill for the hammer screw. I heated it red and dropped it into sand. No go. I heated it red in the sand, and let it cool...again, no go. I went out to the Rod and Gun Club and picked up a big cookie tin full of ashes from our fire place, heated it red, dripped it into the ashes...again, no go. Now I've spent many many hours, ruined several number dirlls, or at least dulled them well, all to no avail.
I called Tom Curran, and then Cody Tetachuck, and they both gave me the same advice. So, I built a little birch wood fire behind the shed, and when I had a nice bed of coals, I took my portable oxy/act. set out to the fire, heated the tumbler red hot, and dropped it into the coals. After about three hours the fire was out, and I could pick up the tumbler.
It drilled like a piece of brass. Le voila!