Jim, Been reviewing all the posts complementing your gun and realized I missed your first question regarding Reedy and the war of 1812. We know Reedy was still with Bonewitz in Pine Grove in 1814 when he marched to Reading to enlist in the defense of Baltimore. He was accompanied by two of Bonewitz' sons and Henry Eckler, another Pine Grove gunsmith. Whether they carried their rifles or not is not known. The records provide the dates, length of march, time of service and pay. Pretty interesting stuff.
Regarding the star on the cheek piece. I have seen them in brass and silver. They were quite common and available from a local whitesmith or silversmith.
The real interesting part about Womelsdorf hardware was the consistency of each parts size. I have reviewed butt plates, side plates and trigger guards that were interchangeable from Bonewitz' earliest guns to Reedy's made 25 and 30 years later. The shop must have used Bonewitz' original molds during all those years or they made up 100's from the get go. HIB