TKS Bob - I might have been a pound out on the Hawken's weight - seems to me now, it's 12 pounds 3oz. (wrong- it is 11 pounds) I know his Sharps is 11 1/2 pounds,while mine is 12 pounds 6 ounces, 2 pounds over limit for BPCR competition, I think - oh well.
Seems today, people are weak (or lazy) in comparison to those hunters and frontiersman of yesteryear. Rifles today seem so light to me compared with the guns our forefathers packed and shot.
Records of Sharps (Sellers) at 18 pounds, Harry Pope writing that a man's offhand rifle should be 16 pounds and a woman's 12 pounds (yes they had butt hooks, but people complain about muzzle weight on their weak left arms) - that sort of thing.
I had a man complain last year at the gun show, that my .32 Squirrel rifle was too heavy as he was attempting to sight it at a far light in the coliseum's ceiling corner. That thing only weighs 7# 12 oz. I had even replaced the 5/16's" rod with the hickory one - I use the steel rod and at 8# 9oz., it's still too light, yet with the hickory, it was too heavy for him - interesting.
I say make the gun heavy enough so it can be shot accurately and if too heavy, work out a bit.