I think either Jim Chambers or Jim Kibler could provide better information about the use of 8620 or 1095 steel for lock parts. 8620 has excellent properties and can be hardened in and of itself as can 1095 (without any additional "case" diffusion of carbon into the surface). However, I have mentioned in other posts, that when attempting to re-harden frizzens that I had annealed to engrave (and that I believe some were cast out of 8620), I have never been successful following the instructions, as an example, provided by Jim Chambers. I am not questioning their correctness, it's just that despite my best efforts they have never worked for me. I have used every available option for heating.....torch, forge, electric furnace with carbon pack, etc.....but a quench in even the correct heat treating oil (as recommended) has never resulted in a frizzen hard enough to produce sparks. The only way I have been able to get an annealed frizzen back in commission has been to torch heat to a bright red, apply Kasenit to the face, and then quench in brine. I know that there is a risk of cracking the part with a quench that fast, but I have never broken one yet and it works every time. Part of the problem may be that in following the recommended procedure I am somehow depleting the surface of the part of carbon and it takes the Kasenit treatment to restore it. I'm not sure but would welcome any information about how to do this better.
As I said, Jim and Jim, are undoubtedly in a much better position to comment since they are in the business of making locks professionally and I have never had a lock from either that was not top notch. Jim Kibler's frizzens are, I believe, cast of 1095 steel. Jim Chamber's are of 8620.
Jim Kibler's comment here is much appreciated and, on the next go around with one of his locks, I will delete the Kasenit portion of my process. I also do not draw the hardening of the face and I agree the harder the better. I use a Presto-lite air / acetylene torch primarily to heat the frizzen quickly to quenching heat. A hardware store propane torch is a little too whimpy for fast heating. The faster this is done the less fire scale is produced on the part. Too much fire scale ruins the polished surface. To eliminate the fire scale entirely I use an anti scale compound from Brownells. You can also use sodium silicate (water glass) as an anti scale compound and it can be had much less expensively.
I also use iron wire to make a quick handle for the frizzen. Here I am coating the annealed, engraved frizzen with a ceramic coating so I can reharden the frizzen without a lot of oxidation on the surface. I do not coat the face of the frizzen as this would retard the quench in that area and the face would not harden properly.

