I just came across this thread from awhile back and being from NY I'd love to believe it was made here. But my first impression before I even read the posts was, German and probably from there based on the artwork and high level of execution in particular. Unless, possibly, it was made in the Mohawk Valley which was still heavily German at the time. In which case a very talented, formally trained man built this in this style and in that area. Which is of course possible. I'm really just curious about this one and have no 'axe to grind' either way. To me it's just so.., well, German. The only thing missing seems to be a boar in the engraving. Thanks, Fred