Hi,
When I want a darker tone on cherry, I use lye; specifically, EasyOff oven cleaner sprayed into a dish and diluted with water. Multiple applications quickly darken/redden the cherry. But keeping it pretty diluted allows me to get the tone I want through multiple weak applications without killing it on the first pass with a heavy one..
In assessing that tone, it's important to wet the wood with water or mineral spirits, as that brings out the actual finished look. Just going off the dry wood.... that's a dull yellow-brown color that's not representative of what it will look like finished.
Best of luck! Cherry is such a beautiful wood.
- Tom