Alright, sounds like smooth is the way to go then. Thanks for weighing in, guys.
Dave, I’m actually working over an L&R Queen Anne lock, using your write-up as my guide. I want to get good at lock work so I bought that one specifically so I could follow along. With the goal being “learning through challenge,” I guess I lucked out! It has a three-position sear, weak frizzen spring, and a pan-frizzen “fit” you could mistake for a coin slot on a pay phone. But I’m really enjoying it and learning a ton — thanks for putting it together. The frizzen will be smooth, too!